728x90
Natural Childbirth

The Pros and Cons of Unassisted Birth

Is Unassisted Birth for You?

Unassisted Births-The Pros and Cons of This New Birthing TrendThere's a definite trend in maternity wards, and in society at large, to make giving birth a more natural experience, more like some think nature intended it to be: quiet support, little intervention and a mobile woman in charge of her own body.

Taking that trend to the next step is the much smaller movement toward unassisted birth, which is giving birth at home without the assistance of any type of medical professional, including midwives. Instead, the mother may be assisted by her spouse or partner, a relative or good friend or she may just be alone.

The Right to Choose
The reasons a woman would choose to give birth unassisted are varied and complex. When Laura Shanley, founder of UnassistedChildbirth.com, chose to do so in the 1970s and 1980s, she insists it wasn't a "hippie" decision or any kind of social protest; she merely wanted to get back to basics in the area of childbirth. She and her husband had been studying the history and psychology of childbirth, as well as birthing options, for two years before she ever became pregnant. When she did get pregnant, they felt there was no one else who could ensure they got the birth experience they wanted.

Unassisted birth is giving birth at home without the assistance of any type of medical professional, including midwives

"At that point we'd already learned so much it seemed like we would have to educate and train anyone we brought into the process," Shanley says. "We felt we had a good, intuitive understanding of why things go wrong in birth, and, intellectually, we felt we could do this."

The Shanleys went on to have four more children at home (one of whom did not survive due to a genetic condition that had nothing to do with the birthing process) and Laura Shanley became an advocate for unassisted childbirth, even authoring the book, Unassisted Childbirth (Bergin & Garvey, 1994). She says that since then, although birthing rooms have been made homier and other aesthetic improvements have been made to the birthing atmosphere, women still have few choices once they either go to a hospital or allow a midwife to become part of their birthing experience.


pages: 1 2 3 4
WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING ABOUT...

The Pros and Cons of Unassisted Birth

Post as:
Comment Text:
 
CAPTCHA:
Please note that any comments submitted become the property of Disney Family / iParenting and can be edited and posted at our discretion.
 
cancel
Shara says
December 20, 2009

I agree with anon., although I wish they had chosen to stand out. I also firmly believe that women make choises that they feel the safest with, and that with proper preparation and a low risk pregnancy, UC can be every bit as healthy and safe, (maybe more so) than hospital birth.

Anonymous says
December 17, 2009

It is my experience that women and men who choose have an unassisted birth do ample research on the subject. Whereas doctors are trained to do what is necessary in emergency and high risk situations, these women train in this as well as how to listen to your own body signals. The problem lies in the fact that in hospitals, every woman is treated the same - as if they were high risk patients, pregnancy is not an illness or disease, and nor is labor. All of this is as natural as conception, and should be looked at this way.

Content provided on this site is for educational purposes only and should not be construed to be medical advice, diagnosis or treatment.
Click here for additional information.

Welcome, please join our community!
New guest? Sign up!   Returning guest? Sign in!
This content requires flash player 9. Click here to upgrade your flash player.
award winning baby nursery essentials
300x250
SOUND OFF! VOTE & DISCUSS

What is your biggest pregnancy fear?

  results
AWARD WINNING PRODUCTS
JOIN THE BOOK CLUB

Join the Pregnancy Today Book Club for some great reads. More >

GALLERIES

728x90